April 28, 2022
USMEF official points out growing concerns over feed supply due to war in Ukraine
Some red meat trade could be affected by the war in Ukraine but it's the animal feed segment that is most concerning, said US Meat Export Federation vice president of economic analysis Erin Borror.
"On the red meat side, Russia, Ukraine and Belarus combined, I think exported maybe around 60,000 tonnes of beef to China, so there is a little bit of red meat trade that gets interesting, but where it really matters is on the feed side," Borror said. "Ukraine is the number three corn exporter, number two barley exporter, number one sunflower exporter, and number five on wheat and Russia has been the largest wheat exporter, so there's obviously growing concern about feed availability."
This is especially concerning for Europe as Ukraine supplies 40% of the European Union's imports of corn, barley and wheat. For China, Ukraine supplies about 23% of those same imports.
"On the feed side, there's real concern about availability because not only are we worried about this crop that should be planted right now, but also the grain in storage that was still to be exported for the rest of this crop year and those exports are not going out of the Ukrainian ports right now," Borror said. "They're working to try to do some grain trade by rail into Europe, but basically, you're looking at product that's still yet to ship not going, and then real questions about the current crop and whether Ukraine can get it in the ground."
That uncertainty with feed supply could prompt further reductions in European hog production. Borror said Europe has already been reducing their herds as pork prices have been under pressure since African swine fever (ASF) was detected in Germany in September 2020.
"That really exacerbated a downturn in Europe's pig prices and then you had China’s demand, essentially evaporating last summer, so mid of 2021, and so European producers were losing money and that's before we see war in Ukraine," Borror added.
In December, Europe's pig inventory was down 3% and sow inventory down 3.6%. There were also steep decreases in Germany specifically, which, Borror said, is the combination of ASF and additional animal welfare and environmental regulations and the costs associated with those that have been impacting pork producers.
"There's contraction underway already in Europe and then you add on higher, even higher, feed costs and real concerns about availability," Borror explained. "In the very immediate situation, we've seen those European pig prices jump by like 35% over the past month and we're starting to close that gap. Where we have been at a premium — the US has been at a premium to Europe since March of 2021 — and that's not normal. Usually, we're the lower cost producer and thus lower price and we've been out of whack since for over a year now."
The impacts on global food systems will likely stretch beyond this growing season.
"They should be planting now," Borror said. "I've heard completely mixed reports on how that may or may not progress, but we also know there's poor infrastructure damage. We know there's concern about ships not wanting to sail into a war zone, so you have both likely limited production, likely curtailed exports out of Ukraine, tight global balance sheets, even before this."
On the feed side, Borror expected the impact to be significant and something that's going to last at least into next year, if not the next two years.
"And then you have all these knock-on effects, what inflation does in these economies and especially in the more developing countries and the concern about food availability and pricing and the ripple impacts across the world," Borror noted.