June 29, 2011

 

Netherlands approves religious animal slaughter ban

The Dutch parliament passed a bill on Tuesday (Jun 28) banning livestock slaughter without stunning first, removing an exemption to butcher animals according to the Jews' and Muslims' ancient dietary rules.

 

If enacted and enforced, religious groups say observant Jews and Muslims would have to import meat from abroad, stop eating it altogether, or leave the Netherlands.

 

However, the bill must still pass the Senate, which is unlikely before the summer recess, and the Cabinet said Monday the law may be unenforceable in its current form due in part to ambiguity introduced in a last-minute amendment.

 

If the Netherlands outlaws procedures that make meat kosher for Jews or halal for Muslims, it will be the second country after New Zealand to do so in recent years. It will join Switzerland, the Scandinavian and Baltic countries, whose bans are mostly traceable to pre-World War II anti-Semitism.

 

"The Cabinet will give its judgment over the proposed law after it has been treated by both houses," said Deputy Secretary of Economic Affairs and Agriculture Henk Blekers. The Cabinet will "also look at how it fits with freedom of religion," he said, citing the European Convention on Human Rights.

 

Lawmaker Marianne Thieme of the Party for the Animals-the world's first animal rights party to win seats in a national parliament-welcomed the approval of the bill that she had first introduced in 2008, and said she was now prepared to defend it in the Senate.

 

But the threat of a possible ban has led to outcry from Jewish and Muslim groups who say it infringes on their right to freedom of religion.

 

Around one million Muslims live in the Netherlands, mostly immigrants from Turkey and Morocco. The once-strong Jewish community now numbers 40,000-50,000 after more that 70% were deported and killed by the Nazis during World War II.

 

"The Dutch Jewish community is small and the Jewish kosher meat consumption is smaller still, but the impact on our community is deep and large," stated a committee of rabbis pleading with parliament not to pass the law in an open letter on Tuesday. "Older Jews are frightened and wonder what the next law will be that limits their religious life. The youth are openly asking whether they still have a future that they can or want to build in the Netherlands."

 

A solid majority of Dutch voters say they support the ban, and parliament voted for it by a margin of 116 for to 30 against.

 

Ritual slaughter rules prescribe that animals' throats must be cut swiftly with a razor-sharp knife while they are still conscious, so that they bleed to death quickly.

 

Only Christian parties were opposed, arguing the ban undermines the country's long tradition of religious tolerance.

 

Science is divided as to whether ritual slaughter does cause more suffering.

 

The Royal Dutch Veterinary Association says it believes that during "slaughter of cattle while conscious, and to a lesser extent that of sheep, the animals' well-being is unacceptably damaged."

 

Other observers, including noted American welfare expert Temple Grandin of Colorado State University, has said animals do not appear to show more distress when a ritual slaughter is conducted properly.